Auckland Road is not dangerous

So said a number of locals at a meeting to discuss safety called by local councillors, Patsy Cummings and Nina Degrads. Why should so many people unconcerned about safety turn up to a meeting to discuss safety? Could they be worried that the only sensible solution to promote safety would involve restricting motorised traffic? There were also other locals who recounted their observations of danger, including a young father who relayed that his children were too frightened by traffic to wish to walk independently to school.

As well as ‘lived experience’, another way of assessing safety is to look at the facts.

Continue reading “Auckland Road is not dangerous”

DfT changes road traffic estimates

On 28 September 2022, the Department for Transport carried out a Minor roads traffic estimate review. Low Traffic Neighbourhood enemies claim this means we don’t need LTNs. We will leave Jon Burke FRSA to explain (16 reasons) why this is untrue.

Check out Jon’s tweets
Continue reading “DfT changes road traffic estimates”

Time for LTNs in Bromley

Bromley residents are now crying out for more safety on their streets. But will the car-loving Tory Bromley Council listen to their pleas?

Low Traffic Neighbourhoods are a policy initiative of the Tory government, yet backwoods Bromley Tories oppose them, championing the ‘rights’ of motorists to drive everywhere.

But are constraints to driving totally alien in Bromley? In fact, Bromley Council deploy most available methods of controlling traffic: chicanes, reducing lane width, one-way streets, 20mph speed limits, speed bumps, and dare we say LTNs, though no doubt they call them something else. Back in August 2020, our active travel correspondent Katie Crowe took a cycle tour of the area and identified many LTNs that have been around for decades (What we talk about when we talk about filtering).

Continue reading “Time for LTNs in Bromley”

Residents deplore return of rat-run traffic

Residents who walked more when rat-running traffic was removed have spoken out. 

Report and videos by road safety campaigner Lee Baker

Resident Jane left her car behind for a lot of trips when the low traffic neighbourhood was in place. Since high traffic is back on her streets, Jane, who lives off Avenue Road, says: “It’s really unpleasant to walk or cycle and I don’t do it as much now.” 

Continue reading “Residents deplore return of rat-run traffic”

A study of rat-run traffic on Auckland Road

Given the quantity of data measured by DfT and other authorities, you would expect to find any number of studies into rat-run traffic. But no. Traffic statistics galore; traffic evaporation, yes. Even our favourite Rachel Aldred, Professor in Transport at the University of Westminster specialising in active mobility, appears to have only published a think-piece.

But the provision of more data from the Speedvisor device on Auckland Road gives us the opportunity to delve into this pernicious phenomenon.

Continue reading “A study of rat-run traffic on Auckland Road”

Holmesdale Road residents live in hope

Report and videos by local road safety campaigner Lee Baker

Local residents are waiting to see if their streets will stay as neighbourly, healthy streets or turned back into traffic-clogged cut-throughs.

Community leader Angela said that removing rat-running from Holmesdale Road meant people wanted to spend time together on the street. 

Continue reading “Holmesdale Road residents live in hope”

TMAC must keep Healthy Streets

Report and videos by road safety campaigner Lee Baker

Road safety

Parents of Oasis Academy Ryelands children have spoken out as councillors decide on the future of their low traffic neighbourhood.

Karina, David and Stoyanka said that the Albert Road healthy streets scheme or LTN had made it safer and easier to walk with their children to school.

Continue reading “TMAC must keep Healthy Streets”

Dangerous streets: everyday cycling in the ex-LTN

Report by a local safety campaigner

One day this week I cycled to do my weekly shop in a nearby supermarket, a round trip of around three miles.

I’m approaching the age when I won’t be able any longer to claim I am middle-aged. I choose to cycle this errand because it gives me some healthy exercise during an often desk/zoom-bound day, and to avoid using my car for a short, local, journey when there is a workable alternative, and I doubt the car would be materially quicker.  Doing my bit for air quality and traffic congestion. Walking wouldn’t work, because of the distance and time, and because I can’t carry on foot nearly as much as I can pack on my bike.  I should make it clear that I have been cycling for over 50 years.  I am a qualified driver too.  I am cautious and I am experienced at anticipating poor behaviour by other road users.

I resumed cycling in summer 2020 when Croydon Council put in place a number of healthy or low traffic neighbourhoods.  (I had stopped a few years before after several scares, including a driver threatening to kill me for no apparent reason other than he objected to my presence on the road.) The one I live in, and one nearby, provided me with a nearly traffic free cycling route to the supermarket.  Unfortunately, the council was panicked into dismantling the one in my neighbourhood after just six months.  The planned modified scheme has not been implemented, five months after the council Cabinet signed it off.  So roughly half my journey is now on back streets carrying main road volumes of traffic.

Continue reading “Dangerous streets: everyday cycling in the ex-LTN”

Where is the need for ANPR, Councillor Ali?

So asks Open Our Roads when publishing this graph:

OOR graph of traffic on Auckland Road (one direction only): click to enlarge

One of their own supporters provides an answer: “Why are we playing theyre games? How does showing thousands of cars going through this road help us get rid of this?”

We note the concern about unreasonable volumes. Having said that, we’ll look at a few more complexities.

Continue reading “Where is the need for ANPR, Councillor Ali?”

Croydon Streetspace – Crystal Palace LTN, an analysis of collision data

Executive Summary

In Summer 2020, LB Croydon introduced Streetspace LTN measures in response to the COVID-19 pandemic as part of the national (DfT) and regional (TfL) Streetspace programme.

The measures appear to have reduced personal injury collisions in the LTN area and at its junctions with the main road network by around 70%, against an increase in overall collisions at borough level. 

The injury collision rate on boundary main roads was not observed to have increased, and overall the observed injury collision rate across the area (the LTN plus its boundary main roads) is 20% lower than expected.

It is likely that around six or seven injury collisions were prevented over the six month period during which the measures were in effect, and that a similar effect would be observed pro rata in a longer trial.

A strong positive effect on reducing collision rates was observed both within the LTN itself, and at the boundary junctions where minor roads meet the main road network.

However, the short time period that the measures were in place for (just 6 months), and the inability of this study to measure risk exposure (in terms of injuries per person/km walked or cycled), means that these figures are subject to some degree of uncertainty.

A longer trial period backed by detailed traffic counts for both active travel modes (to measure risk exposure) and motor vehicles (to assess traffic volumes and road user behaviour) would provide a more statistically robust result – an 18 month trial would be expected to prevent around 20 injuries across the area road network if the observed trend is shown to be correct.

Given the overall profile of injury collisions on local roads, Streetspace LTN measures cannot be considered a panacea, and further Streetspace trials should be supported by complementary measures to improve safety on main roads – in particular, improved pedestrian facilities at main road junctions.

Continue reading “Croydon Streetspace – Crystal Palace LTN, an analysis of collision data”

Our LTN will prevail

Hokusai: The Great Wave off Kanagawa

Why are we so confident that our Low Traffic Neighbourhood in Upper Norwood will win in the end? It’s simple. The tide of history has changed.

The onslaught of car dominance over people started in the 1950s. In cities, trams and trolleybuses were removed. Buildings were bulldozed to make way for roads. In rural areas the rail network was decimated.

Continue reading “Our LTN will prevail”

Submission to Scrutiny & Overview Committee

Dear Committee Members

This email is on behalf of Shape Better Streets, a resident campaign for traffic reduction and active travel in the LTN area you will be discussing next week.  We broadly support Cllr Ali’s decision to reinstate the LTN in modified form.

Continue reading “Submission to Scrutiny & Overview Committee”

Some questions for the Scrutiny Committee

The fate of Auckland Road as a Healthy Street experiment is about to come under scrutiny. It is almost unbelievable that there would be any opposition to a Healthy Street, but sadly these questions need to be answered.

Continue reading “Some questions for the Scrutiny Committee”

Auckland Road in Utopia

It looks like Auckland Road will become the backbone of an experimental ANPR controlled Healthy Streets scheme. But instead of a watered-down 2nd generation Low Traffic Neighbourhood, how would we design it if we genuinely wanted to demonstrate what a people friendly neighbourhood could really look like?

Croydon Council has talented highway engineers who must be praying to do more than just put in ANPRs. What would they deliver if they worked in the Netherlands, Denmark, or Germany?

Continue reading “Auckland Road in Utopia”

LTNs and Equalities

Opponents of LTNs, in this area and elsewhere, frequently assert that they have adverse impacts on the groups in our society who are legally protected under equalities legislation.  This blog takes a dispassionate look at the evidence and finds these claims at best unsubstantiated, and in some cases completely unsupported, on the balance of evidence.

Continue reading “LTNs and Equalities”

Telraam traffic counters coming to Crystal Palace

Click to enlarge

A local initiative is taking off to inform the debate around traffic management and policy in Crystal Palace. Volunteers are installing a number of stand-alone traffic counters using Raspberry Pi devices running Telraam software. This is an open source traffic-counting system that has been developed by a team in Belgium specifically to promote citizen science-led traffic policy.

Continue reading “Telraam traffic counters coming to Crystal Palace”

Open letter to Councillor Muhammad Ali

1 February 2021

Dear Muhammad


Residents and supporters of our campaign were dismayed to read your announcement that the current LTN measures will be taken out before the implementation of the planned new experimental layout, and, indeed, before there is any clarity about the timetable on which it will be implemented.  I am sure you realise, but I must put on record, that a return to being a high traffic neighbourhood will have a devastating impact on well-being and quality of life for residents, particularly many with protected characteristics, and reverse the enormous progress which has been made in encouraging active travel. 

Continue reading “Open letter to Councillor Muhammad Ali”

Theory of relativity

For centuries, we were quite happy to think that time was constant until Einstein spoilt everything by advancing his theory that time was relative. But it has taken the advent of our local LTN for oppositionists to posit that a road that takes 5 minutes 10 seconds to cycle is causing 40 minute delays to car journeys.

So we thought we should provide some context. Here you can see how people are adapting to the new safe environment that is Auckland Road (and Lancaster Road):

Continue reading “Theory of relativity”

Planters into chicanes

Xmas tree on Stambourne Way planter

Whatever might be in store for the LTN, one thing for sure is that the planters will become redundant. Here’s a proposal to make use of them that requires the least effort or transport costs. Some members of our community clearly like their planters, so this proposal offers continuity for them to care for and decorate ‘their’ planters.

Continue reading “Planters into chicanes”

It wasn’t a vote

Some of our local representatives seem to have been caught up in the meme that the opponents of the LTN ‘won the vote’. If they had been paying attention, rather than getting caught up in OOR hysteria, they should have spotted that it was a consultation. So looking beyond the simplicity of the numbers let’s see what this consultation actually revealed.

The most striking feature was that 75% of residents were so unconcerned about the LTN that they did not think it was worth responding.

Continue reading “It wasn’t a vote”

Why restrictions need to be kept at the bus gate

Supporters of the LTN broadly support the proposals in the officers’ report to the Traffic Management Advisory Committee, though some would prefer that the LTN was preserved in its current format with planters.

However, almost unanimously, we believe that permitting local residents to drive through the bus gate undermines some of the objectives of the LTN.

Continue reading “Why restrictions need to be kept at the bus gate”

Claims made by the Open Our Roads campaign – Myth & Reality

The Open Our Roads campaign can only support its ludicrous demands to open roads which are, in fact, already open, by resorting to claims for which they can produce no evidence.  Here we take a look at a few of them.

Continue reading “Claims made by the Open Our Roads campaign – Myth & Reality”

Letter to TMAC councillors

Traffic Management Advisory Committee 12 January 2021

Dear Committee Members

This email is on behalf of Shape Better Streets, a resident campaign for traffic reduction and active travel in the LTN area you will be discussing next week.  We broadly support the proposals in the officer paper.

Continue reading “Letter to TMAC councillors”

Evaporating traffic

The phenomenon of evaporating traffic is so interesting that we devote a sub-section to it on our Resources page. Opponents of LTNs all over the world like to claim that restricting traffic in one area just displaces it to another. This may well happen over a short period, but quite quickly, enough people change their mode of travel so that overall traffic reduces and in some cases it even happens on the boundary roads.

But now for something completely different.

This post is going to look for a more mysterious form of disappearing traffic, as it has apparently occurred without intervention, nobody has spotted it nor divined where it might have gone.

Continue reading “Evaporating traffic”

Devastating debunking of LTN raison d’être

It is the season to be magnanimous so it is only fitting that we should admit that opponents of the LTN have finally supplied the killer blow to our attempts to demonstrate that traffic patterns over the last 10 years prove the need for the LTN.

Continue reading “Devastating debunking of LTN raison d’être”